Creative Tutors of Dallas - Highland Park
« President Obama's Back to School Message :: Highland Park ISD change in class rank policy »This article from the Washington Post looks at what it refers to as the "sleeping giant" of America's education system...home-schooling. According to the article, 1.7 million children are currently being home-schooled and this number has been growing by about 9% each year for the last ten years. The big question about home-schooled children is whether or not they receive the same quality of education as children attending public schools.
Follow up:
The fear of many publilc school educators is that they may not be. The parents of home-schooled children must have the best intentions but do they have the experience? Regulation by the government of home-schooling has gone down in the last few years, but will this always be the case? Because good data of home-schooled situations is hard to come by, a man named Robert Kunzman, an associate professor at the Indiana University School of Education and a former high school teacher, decided to do a study and write a book about this subject. Kunzman observed six home-schooling families from around the country and found both good and bad practices, just like in any public school. And, he did not concur with popular opinion that homeschooled children are not being socialized in the same way as children who attend public school. He did find, however, that parents tend to teach and focus on what they know, leaving less familiar subjects neglected.
As far as regulation goes, Kunzman says this is only justified when 1) vital interests of children or society are at stake, 2) there is general consensus on standards for meeting those interests, and 3) there is an effective way to measure whether those standards are met. So how is academic accountability for home-schoolers best achieved? According to Kunzman, the answer is to test these children on basic skills, just as public school children are tested.
As a former public school teacher myself I admit that I have always had the same concerns about home-schooled children...are they being taught all subjects, are they being socialized? After reading this article though, I agree with it and realize that bad teaching is something that can happen both in the home environment and in the school environment. But, as this article states, as the number of home-schooled children increases, this will continue to be a subject of much debate.
09/04/09 @ 08:53Almost every state in the US requires home schools to test their children at regular intervals, most require yearly standardized tests.
Overall, homeschoolers outperform their traditionally schooled peers (both private and public schools) on standardized tests. Unlike most public schools, homeschoolers do not teach to the test. Unlike public schools whose funding is dependent on performing well (thanks to no child left behind) homeschools are exempt from those regulations. About testing, the outperforming holds true across all socio-economic and racial lines.
The stereo-type of homeschool where the parents make up the curriculum, live on a compound, and seclude the kids away is riddiculous. Most of us use some form of printed or online curriculum, many homeschool parents have college degrees, and all of us believe that we are more capable of teaching our children than the public school system.
Little Rock Homeschooling Examiner
Comments are not allowed from anonymous visitors.
Kellye Ambler graduated from Texas A & M University with a degree in Journalism and Marketing. She has been in the education field since 2001; teaching Pre-Kindergarten and as an Assistant Director at an NAEYC accredited private preschool. For the past three years she has been a substitute teacher in her local school district, teaching mainly at the elementary level in the Special Education department. Kellye and her husband, Jim, keep busy with their two boys, ages 12 and 2.